Well.. answering of my friend's question about eyeliners, here i am trying to do some review. Hope it'll help you out for finding a great and affordable one for yourself. Enjoy :)
Etude Eye Liner Gel - I bought this in Jakarta around $8 (February Haul) |
Etude - PIXY - Mirabella - PIXY - Target - Sari Ayu |
This one is my favourite, i love the thick applicator |
Etude Eyeliner Brush comes in set with the Eye Liner Gel |
That pretty much eyeliner that i can find in my traincase for now, the maybeline waterproof eye liner already finish :D that used to be my Holy Grail eyeliner, but this PIXY does the job also.
Let's move on to the swatches, shall we ladies?
swatches - indoor with flash |
From left to right :
Etude Eye Liner Gel - PIXY - Mirabella - PIXY pencil eye liner - Target Pencil Eye Liner - Sari Ayu
The way i see it, PIXY liquid eye liner is still the blackest, too bad i can't compare it with my late maybelline :D
after washes and rub 3 times with plain water |
Finaly let me do the review, will try my best to explain. Be patient with me ladies hehe..
DESCRIPTION | ETUDE | PIXY - LIQUID | MIRABELLA | PIXY - PENCIL | NO BRAND - TARGET | SARI AYU |
COLOR | THICK BLACK | VERY THICK BLACK | BLACK | BLACK | THICK BLACK | THICK BLACK |
DENSITY | OK | SUPER | ACCEPTABLE | OK | SUPER | OK |
STAYING POWER | SO-SO | SUPER | OK | OK, BUT FOR LOWER LASHLINE CAN BE SMUDGING SOMETIMES | OK | OK |
CLEANING | EASY TO CLEAN BUT A BIT MESSY | NEED REMOVER OR CLEANSING MILK | EASY TO CLEAN WITH ONLY FACIAL CLEANSER | NEED REMOVER OR CLEANSING MILK | NEED REMOVER OR CLEANSING MILK | WATER AND FACIAL WASH WILL DO |
PRICE | 75K OR $8 | 28K OR $3 | 31K OR $3 | 18K OR $2 | DUNNO – COMES WITH SETS | 38K OR $4 |
REPURCHASE | NO, WILL TRY OTHER GEL LINER (DROLLING FOR L’OREAL HIP OR WET N WILD) | YES | YES, FOR DOING CLIENT’S EYES | YES | NOPE | NOPE |
nice review sis! look forward for pixy eyeliner,
ReplyDeletewill try it after read ur comment! seems nice and the price oso :)
thank u :)
ReplyDeletewill review soon... i quite like this, the minus is only it's not waterproof, but do last on ur lid tho' quite a bargain for the price, yeah :)