Review and Swatches of Eyeliner + Addition of February Haul

I'm such a clumsy baby... I feel from the stair after lunch, just in time where i had to go to the bank and campus. Great!! Now i'm stuck at home, blogging... Well i'm not complaining but it give bruises and crack my toe nail. That one hurts and gross, it's better not to upload picture i think. Hiks..

Well.. answering of my friend's question about eyeliners, here i am trying to do some review. Hope it'll help you out for finding a great and affordable one for yourself. Enjoy :)

Etude Eye Liner Gel - I bought this in Jakarta around $8 (February Haul)

Etude - PIXY - Mirabella - PIXY - Target - Sari Ayu

This one is my favourite, i love the thick applicator

Etude Eyeliner Brush comes in set with the Eye Liner Gel

That pretty much eyeliner that i can find in my traincase for now, the maybeline waterproof eye liner already finish :D that used to be my Holy Grail eyeliner, but this PIXY does the job also.


Let's move on to the swatches, shall we ladies?

swatches - indoor with flash

The swatches was taken inside my room, probabbly not enough light. But i hope you ladies can see it pretty clearly :D
From left to right :
Etude Eye Liner Gel - PIXY - Mirabella - PIXY pencil eye liner - Target Pencil Eye Liner - Sari Ayu
The way i see it, PIXY liquid eye liner is still the blackest, too bad i can't compare it with my late maybelline :D

after washes and rub 3 times with plain water

This is after i washes my hand and rub all of them together and rub it 3 times. I didn't used any soap tho' because i want you guys to see and probably predict how it's gonna look like after outdoor activities with sweat and everything so i wet it.

Finaly let me do the review, will try my best to explain. Be patient with me ladies hehe..

DESCRIPTION	ETUDE	PIXY - LIQUID	MIRABELLA	PIXY - PENCIL	NO BRAND - TARGET	SARI AYU
COLOR	THICK BLACK	VERY THICK BLACK	BLACK	BLACK	THICK BLACK	THICK BLACK
DENSITY	OK	SUPER	ACCEPTABLE	OK	SUPER	OK
STAYING POWER	SO-SO	SUPER	OK	OK, BUT FOR LOWER LASHLINE CAN BE SMUDGING SOMETIMES	OK	OK
CLEANING	EASY TO CLEAN BUT A BIT MESSY	NEED REMOVER OR CLEANSING MILK	EASY TO CLEAN WITH ONLY FACIAL CLEANSER	NEED REMOVER OR CLEANSING MILK	NEED REMOVER OR CLEANSING MILK	WATER AND FACIAL WASH WILL DO
PRICE	75K OR $8	28K OR $3	31K OR $3	18K OR $2	DUNNO – COMES WITH SETS	38K OR $4
REPURCHASE	NO, WILL TRY OTHER GEL LINER (DROLLING FOR L’OREAL HIP OR WET N WILD)	YES	YES, FOR DOING CLIENT’S EYES	YES	NOPE	NOPE